After the portrait’s completion in France in 1869, it was sent to the White House to join the Executive Mansion’s growing collection of presidential portraits. President Grant, however, did not find the portrait suitable and selected another Lincoln portrait by William F. Cogswell. Robert Todd Lincoln, the eldest son of President Lincoln, bought the Healy portrait, remarking later in life, “I have never seen a portrait of my father which is to be compared with it in any way.”

Seventy years later in 1939, the portrait finally made its way to the White House at the bequest of Mary Harlan Lincoln, wife of Robert Todd Lincoln. She originally gave the portrait to her daughter, Mary Lincoln Isham, to possess for the remainder of her life. The portrait was then to be given to the United States government “provided it be given an appropriate place in the White House in Washington.” This took place upon the death of Mary Lincoln Isham in November 1938. On January 7, 1939, President Franklin D. Roosevelt wrote to Frederic N. Towers, an executor and trustee of Mary Harlan Lincoln’s will, that it would give him “great pleasure to receive for the White House the Healy portrait.”²

Upon its arrival at the White House, the Healy portrait’s destination remained undecided. One newspaper described the Cogswell portrait preferred by Grant as still hanging in the State Dining Room, but the Healy portrait replaced it shortly thereafter.³ Its subsequent occasional absences from there were only temporary, as presidents either left it above the mantle or later changed their minds and returned it to the State Dining Room. During the Dwight Eisenhower administration, the piece was reportedly relocated elsewhere on the State Floor so school children could view the portrait, as the State Dining Room was often closed during tours in preparation for luncheons and other events. Lincoln was returned to the State Dining Room within the first few weeks of the John F. Kennedy administration.⁴ In 1962, it was briefly replaced by a recently acquired Rembrandt Peale painting of George Washington while it underwent conservation treatment.⁵ Likewise, in 1973, a landscape by Jasper Francis Cropsey temporarily replaced the Healy Lincoln, which was moved to the East Room. White House Curator Clement Conger justified its relocation, reasoning, “we thought the Lincoln portrait looked rather too brooding for that spot.”⁶ Restored to the State Dining Room by President Gerald Ford in August 1974, the painting has been consistently displayed there ever since, and at times serves as a rhetorical tool for presidents while speaking to guests, dignitaries, and visiting heads of state in the historic room.⁷

Given its highly visible location in the White House, it is no surprise the depiction of Lincoln has become a White House favorite. For Christmas in 1971, the Nixons gave White House staff members an 8x10-inch velvet cased photograph of the Healy portrait.⁸ In 1999, Healy’s depiction was used for the official White House Christmas ornament, commissioned by the White House Historical Association.

Despite its initial rejection for display in the White House by President Grant, Healy’s portrait of Lincoln has become an iconic piece of White House artwork, reflecting the country’s interest in, fascination with, and recognition of the significance of its sixteenth president.